Fancied up and added to the Playlists section.
Jay, what is your evidence to support the idea that WDI used the original Perry Kingsley albums instead of the compilation? The fact that the loop uses only songs from the compilation, in the order of the compilation, would lead me to believe it was the compilation that was used (although I will admit that the compilation merely reproduces the original discs in order of release so that could go either way). The box set was released in 2001 which fits the timetable of when we believe the loop was installed.
One word: omission. It makes sense to you that someone used the 3-disc Complete Vanguard Recordings as their source, but failed to include any tracks from Kaleidoscopic Vibrations in the loop? He/she decided to use nearly every track from The In Sound from Way Out!, tracks 1-12 on Disc 1, but then decided to skip tracks 13-26, Kaleidoscopic Vibrations, in favor of moving on to Disc 2? And why did he/she also skip all of Disc 3?Jay, what is your evidence to support the idea that WDI used the original Perry Kingsley albums instead of the compilation?
Precisely. Forget about the compilation for a moment. You can't see that someone used nearly every track (9/12) from The In Sound from Way Out!, followed by nearly every track (12/13) from The Amazing New Electronic Pop Sound of Jean-Jacques Perrey, and then filled the rest of their allotted time with a selection of tracks, grabbed in order, from Moog Indigo? Now, bringing the compilation back into the picture, you don't find it at all odd that this lazy person, who was merely grabbing tracks in sequential order, managed to skip every single track that comprises Kaleidoscopic Vibrations? Ironic, too, since Kaleidoscopic Vibrations is where Baroque Hoedown (Electrical Water Pageant, Main Street Electrical Parade) made its debut.I will admit that the compilation merely reproduces the original discs in order of release
If I had access to a copy of the loop, I'd listen carefully for pops or scratches, which would be a telltale sign that not only were they using the original albums, they were using LPs. Like I said, I've had these and other electronic music albums (e.g., Switched-On Bach, Snowflakes Are Dancing) in my own collection for eons.Now there has been some discussion of the possibility that the loop used in the Star Trader might have been originally compiled for WDW's Tomorrowland in the 70s, which would certainly support the idea that the loop was originally compiled using the original albums and probably by Jack Wagner. But I have yet to see any solid evidence is the case.
I already pointed out that the compilation has the benefit of including the Kaleidoscopic Vibrations tracks. As for cost, that would depend on whether you're going new, used, iTunes/MP3, or the pirate route. Myself, I'd pick up the three original albums on used CDs for about $18 total.I don't see why one wouldn't simply buy the compilation- it's more expensive to buy the individual discs